Mastering the Art of Trolling for Muskie

Most anglers who venture into the world of musky fishing find themselves faced with a pivotal choice – the lady or the tiger scenario of trolling. Some dismiss it as lazy and dull, almost sacrilegious to the sport, while others swear by its effectiveness. Indeed, trolling for muskie requires a scientific approach, but too often, it gets compartmentalized, overshadowing the true artistry behind this fishing technique.

In this comprehensive guide, we aim to unravel the intricacies of trolling for muskie, providing both seasoned and novice anglers with the knowledge to master this technique and significantly increase their chances of landing "the fish of ten thousand casts."

Understanding Muskie Behavior: The Foundation of Successful Trolling

Before setting up your trolling spread, it's crucial to understand the behavior patterns of these elusive predators. Muskies are ambush predators that often inhabit areas with abundant cover. They prefer to station themselves near weed beds and weed edges, underwater drop-offs, rocky structures and reefs, points and breaks, and submerged timber. These locations provide the perfect environment for them to ambush their prey.

These apex predators strike unsuspecting prey with remarkable speed and agility. Their feeding patterns and habitat preferences directly inform your trolling routes, depths, and lure selection. By studying and understanding these patterns, anglers can significantly increase their chances of positioning their presentations where active muskies are most likely to encounter them.

Cory Allen shows muskie trolling techniques and how to catch fish

The Science and Art of Muskie Trolling Techniques

Contrary to the misconception that trolling is simply dragging lures behind a boat, effective muskie trolling combines precision boat handling, strategic speed adjustments, and calculated maneuvers to trigger strikes.

Muskie Fishing Courses

How to Catch Muskie in Open Water with Cory Allen

Muskie - Fishing Open Water with Cory Allen

Featured

Muskie - Trolling Techniques with Cory Allen

Featured

Muskie - Lures for the Spingtime with Cory Allen

Muskie - Glide Baits with Cory Allen

winter musky fishing seminar video with Cory Allen and Chad Bryson

Muskie - Seminar on Wintertime Fishing in the South

Muskie - Fishing the Collins River Fall Transition

Musky Fishing - Post Spawn Collins River

Muskie - Fishing Post Spawn on the Collins River

Muskie Fly Fishing Gear with Chad Bryson

Muskie - Fishing Deep Rivers in the Winter

the CullShad from Berkley is perfect for downsized musky fishing presentations

Berkley CullShad – Great for Cold Weather Musky Fishing

Boat Handling Techniques

Cory Allen, a renowned musky fishing guide featured in our In The Spread muskie fishing videos, emphasizes the importance of mastering boat control. Effective trolling requires precise maneuvering through muskie territory. S-turns and zigzag patterns cause your lures to speed up on the outside of turns and slow down on the inside, creating varying speeds that often trigger strikes from following fish. This variation in pace can be the difference between a follow and a commitment.

Speed variations play a crucial role in triggering strikes. Alternating between slow and fast trolling mimics injured prey and can entice muskies that are following but not committing. Experienced anglers know that muskie strikes often occur during these speed transitions. The art of navigating around structure while maintaining proper lure depth requires practice and precision, but mastering this skill dramatically increases your odds of connecting with trophy fish.

Trolling in Shallow Waters

While many anglers associate trolling with deep water, shallow-water trolling can be incredibly effective, especially during certain seasons. When trolling shallow weed flats and bays, successful anglers run lures at specific distances behind the boat to avoid weeds while maintaining a consistent speed to prevent snagging. Trolling topwater lures is a super effective method for shallow bays.

Maintaining vigilance for underwater hazards such as rocks and stumps is essential when working shallow water. Using detailed lake maps helps identify potential shallow hotspots, saving time and increasing efficiency. The transition areas between shallow weed flats and deeper water often hold actively feeding muskies and should be given special attention during your trolling patterns.

Essential Equipment for Muskie Trolling Success

Rods and Reels

Selecting the right equipment is paramount in musky trolling. Heavy-duty trolling rods in the 8'6" to 9' range provide the backbone needed to handle big muskies and the leverage required for proper hook sets when strikes occur at a distance. Quality reels with robust drag systems are better able to withstand the pressure created by dragging sizable lures at depth, ensuring you can repeat successful patterns once they're established.

Rod positioning creates a well-organized spread that's crucial for covering more of the water column. Most successful muskie trollers develop a system for their rod placements, with each position serving a specific purpose in the overall presentation strategy. Some anglers dedicate specific rods to running close to bottom while others target suspended fish, creating a comprehensive approach to locating active muskies.

Lines and Leaders

The connection between you and trophy muskie requires careful consideration. Mainline selection typically centers around 80-pound braided line like Seaguar Threadlock, which provides the strength to handle powerful fish while maintaining sensitivity to detect subtle changes in lure action or bottom contact.

Leaders deserve equal attention, with 100-130 pound fluorocarbon leaders offering invisibility while providing protection against the muskie's sharp teeth. An 8-foot leader gives adequate separation between the lure and mainline, creating a presentation that appears natural to following fish.

Cory Allen with one of his many giant muskie

Advanced Trolling Spreads and Presentations

Water Column Coverage

I cannot emphasize enough the importance of spreading lures throughout the water column to maximize your chances of locating active fish. This comprehensive approach involves running one lure halfway down for suspended fish while positioning another near the bottom for deep-hugging muskies. During fall, after turnover, focusing on multiple depths becomes particularly important as fish may suspend at various levels in the water column.

The strategic placement of lures at different depths creates a search pattern that efficiently covers the entire water column. When fish show a preference for a particular depth, anglers can adjust their spread to concentrate more presentations in the productive zone. This adaptability separates casual trollers from those who consistently connect with trophy muskies.

Prop Wash Techniques

There's something uniquely effective about running a lure in the prop wash. The turbulence created by your motor creates a distinct vibration and flash pattern that can trigger reaction strikes from following muskies. When setting up a spread, consider placing one rod directly behind the boat to take advantage of this phenomenon.

The prop wash technique proves particularly effective during tough fishing conditions when muskies seem reluctant to commit to standard presentations. The added turbulence can provide just enough extra stimulation to convert followers into strikers. Many of the best muskie fishermen I know maintain that their prop wash rod consistently produces their largest fish of the season.

Seasonal Trolling Strategies

Fall Trolling Tactics

Fall is prime time for trophy muskie trolling as fish feed heavily to prepare for winter. During this season, larger profile lures match the fattened-up baitfish that muskies target. Focusing on mud basins and deeper structure where fish congregate during this time of year can lead to exceptional catch rates.

As water temperatures drop, implementing slower presentations becomes increasingly important. The metabolism of muskies slows with the cooling water, making them less likely to chase fast-moving lures. Average trolling speeds of 2.0 - 3.5 mph work well during early fall, but slowing down in dingy water or as temperatures continue to drop can be the key to continued success as winter approaches. Experiment with speeds to find the sweet spot. I have found that keeping the prop just out of idle, moving very slowly works well.

Summer Trolling Approaches

During summer months, muskie location and behavior create different trolling opportunities. Targeting weed edges and drop-offs adjacent to shallow feeding areas can be productive, especially during early morning and evening hours when fish move shallow to feed. Increased trolling speeds in warmer water match the more active feeding nature of summer muskies.

Summer patterns often require covering vast areas to locate scattered fish. The warmer water temperatures allow muskies to distribute more widely throughout a system, making efficiency in your trolling approach essential. Focusing on early morning and evening trolling typically produces the best results, though overcast days can extend productive periods throughout daylight hours.

Lure Selection for Muskie Trolling

Types of Effective Trolling Lures

The arsenal of effective muskie trolling lures continues to evolve, with several categories proving consistently productive. Spinnerbaits create vibration and flash that's ideal for targeting suspended fish, while Tim Woodyard's custom gliders offer unique action that triggers strikes from even reluctant followers. These specialized presentations make a significant difference when fish have seen common offerings.

Custom-designed twitch baits can be deadly when trolled at varying speeds, and both jointed and straight-bodied crankbaits cover different depth ranges effectively. Large rubber baits like Bull Dawgs work exceptionally well in fall when muskies seek larger profile meals. The diverse selection allows anglers to match presentations to specific conditions and fish preferences.

Color Selection

Matching your lure colors to water conditions and forage base significantly increases your odds of success. In clear water, natural perch patterns and realistic baitfish colors typically outperform brighter options. Stained water calls for more visible presentations, with chartreuse and red/orange combinations cutting through the reduced visibility.

Understanding the dominant forage in your target water helps narrow color selection further. Using silver/white patterns in cisco lakes and gold where walleye are the primary forage creates presentations that match what muskies are accustomed to targeting. This attention to detail can be the difference between a following fish and one that commits to striking.

Proven Triggering Techniques

Successful muskie trolling often hinges on triggering hesitant followers to strike. One particularly effective technique involves bottom contact – when a lure bounces off the bottom, immediately point your rod tip up and momentarily slow down, then speed up and rip the bait forward. This erratic action often triggers reaction strikes from following fish.

Occasional speed bursts create another triggering mechanism that can convert followers into biters. These accelerations mimic fleeing baitfish and can trigger the predatory instinct in following muskies. Sharp turns provide a similar advantage, as outside lines speed up during turns while inside lines slow down, often triggering strikes from fish that have been following without committing.

Embrace the Art of Trolling

Trolling for musky is an art form that blends scientific knowledge with angling skill. By understanding musky behavior, selecting the right equipment, and employing strategic trolling techniques, anglers can significantly increase their chances of success. The approach combines precision, patience, and adaptability – hallmarks of all successful muskie anglers.

Whether you're a seasoned musky hunter or new to the sport, embracing the art of trolling will undoubtedly enhance your fishing experience and potentially lead to the trophy catch of a lifetime. Remember, the debate between casting and trolling need not be contentious – both have their place in the musky angler's arsenal, and the most successful fishermen master both approaches.

For an in-depth visual demonstration of these techniques, check out our In The Spread musky fishing video on Trolling for Muskie, featuring expert guidance from Cory Allen on setting up an effective trolling spread, rod positioning, boat handling, and advanced trolling concepts.

Seth Horne In The Spread,
Chief Creator